Click-Fraud-v2

Digital Advertising Fraud Is a $88B Problem, Bigger Than Credit Card Fraud  

The rapidly evolving digital marketing landscape has, unfortunately, come with new issues that harm businesses. One of the most significant problems is click fraud. What was once a minor issue has ballooned into a $88 billion problem globally — far exceeding the cost of credit card fraud. (Sources: Statista and US News)

While the latter has a more direct impact on consumers, click fraud significantly affects the digital economy. Thanks to this issue, businesses and digital marketers are wasting thousands of dollars on artificial engagements. 

The rise of click fraud is no small matter. It severely affects the digital advertising industry, impacting advertising budgets and campaign effectiveness. This necessitates enhanced security measures and prevention strategies to protect the integrity of digital ad campaigns against sophisticated invalid clicks and suspicious activities. At Connection Model, we aim to inform companies and digital marketing teams about the problem’s scope and how to minimize its effects. With our solutions, you’ll be more equipped to combat online ad fraud and maintain the integrity of your ad campaigns. 

Surprising Findings: 

  • 17.9% of all traffic was fake in 2023
  • Instances of malicious bots increased 32% YoY 
  • Bad actors prefer desktop user agents for enterprise attacks

(Source: Cheq)

What Is Click Fraud and What Are Fraudulent Clicks? 

Click fraud happens when bots, software, and even humans spam click on ads, particularly pay-per-click (PPC) ads, without any intention to purchase the service or product. The primary motivation for click fraud is financial gain, as scammers manipulate digital advertising networks to generate income or deplete the competition's ad budget with invalid traffic. This practice is meant to artificially increase the clicks of the ad, making it seem as though it’s engaging or popular. The inflated number of clicks may also boost search rankings inorganically. 

Types of Ad Fraud 

Ad fraud can take various forms, each posing unique challenges to advertisers. Understanding these types can help businesses better protect their online advertising efforts and ensure genuine engagement with potential customers. 

Click fraud: This is a prevalent form of online advertising fraud where a person, automated script, computer program, or auto clicker mimics a human behavior by clicking on an ad without any genuine interest in the target link. This artificially inflates click numbers, wasting advertising budgets and creating fraudulent traffic. 

Impression fraud: In this common type of ad fraud, fraudsters generate fake ad impressions, often using bot traffic or malware. This inflates the number of ad views, misleading advertisers about the reach and effectiveness of their campaigns. 

Conversion fraud: This involves generating fake conversions, such as form submissions or purchases, to deceive advertisers into paying for non-existent leads. It skews performance metrics and drains marketing budgets. 

Domain spoofing: Fraudsters create fake websites or domains to display ads, tricking advertisers into thinking their ads are shown on legitimate sites. This increases revenue for the fraudsters while providing no real value to the advertiser. 

Ad stacking: This technique involves displaying multiple ads on a single webpage, often hidden behind one another. Users may only see one ad, but multiple ads are counted as viewed, inflating ad impressions and costs. 

Perils-of-fake-traffic-1

The Perils of Fake Traffic: Click Jacking, Malicious Bots, Page Scrapers and Malicious Automation Tools

 

How Digital Ad Fraud Works 

Click fraud is a sophisticated scheme that typically involves several steps to deceive advertisers and ad networks: 

Fraudulent clicks: The process begins with a person, automated script, computer program, or auto clicker imitating a legitimate user by clicking on an ad. These clicks are made without any real interest in the ad’s content, solely to inflate click numbers. 

IP address manipulation: To avoid detection, fraudsters often use fake or stolen IP addresses. This disguises their true location and makes it harder for ad networks to identify the fraudulent activity. 

Cookie manipulation: Fraudsters use cookies to track and manipulate users' browsing behavior. This makes it appear as though the real users are genuinely interested in the ad, further complicating detection efforts. 

Ad network exploitation: Finally, fraudsters exploit vulnerabilities in ad networks to generate fake impressions and clicks. This can involve sophisticated techniques to bypass security measures and maximize their fraudulent gains. 

The Impact of Online Advertising Fraud on Businesses 

The model used in online ads means that every click results in an expense for the company that published the ad. Fake clicks on these ads can lead to significant financial losses and distorted campaign metrics. Click fraud reduces the budget for these ads without yielding results. It may seem like there’s heightened engagement with fake traffic, but the company won’t see this translate into revenue. 

Losing revenue is not the only negative impact of click fraud—it can also skew marketing data. In the marketing world, data is king. We use metrics to analyze campaign performance and look for strengths and weaknesses. Click fraud disrupts these calculations and makes it harder for companies to see the real picture. Fraudsters' malicious activity manipulates fake clicks on competitors' links in organic search results to artificially inflate their search engine rankings. Consequently, the organic traffic of the targeted business diminishes. 

Finally, digital marketers who facilitate PPC campaigns for clients may suffer low retention rates. Given that the latter’s ad budget won’t provide the target return on investment (ROI) because of PPC fraud, they may cast doubt on the agency’s capabilities and feel dissatisfied with the service. Agencies that don’t address this issue may find themselves facing higher client turnover and difficulty attracting new business. 

Sectors Most Affected by Click Fraud 

While click fraud can affect any industry that relies on online advertising, certain sectors are particularly vulnerable: 

E-commerce: Online retailers are prime targets for click fraud. Fraudsters use fake clicks to inflate ad costs, reducing profit margins and skewing performance metrics. 

Finance: Financial institutions and online lenders often face click fraud, where fraudsters generate fake clicks to create leads and potentially steal sensitive information. This not only wastes ad spend but also poses significant security risks. 

Travel: Online travel agencies and travel websites are also susceptible to click fraud. Fraudsters’ fake clicks can lead to wasted ad spend and reduced bookings, impacting overall business performance. 

Examples of Click Fraud 

Click fraud can manifest in several ways, each with its own malicious intent, tactics, and methods: 

  • Botnet attacks: In these attacks, a group of compromised computers or mobile devices, known as a botnet, is used to generate bot clicks on ads. This often involves malware or viruses, making it a widespread and challenging issue to combat. 
  • Click farms: A click farm employs groups of low-paid workers to click on ads repeatedly. These workers often use fake IP addresses and cookies to avoid detection, inflating ad costs and skewing performance data. 
  • Competitor clicks: In a more vicious form of click fraud, competitors click on a rival’s ads to inflate their ad costs and reduce their profit margins. This unethical practice can significantly affect a business’s ad budgets and overall performance. 

Detecting and Preventing Click Fraud with AI Fraud Prevention 

Many fraud detection tools have emerged in recent years to aid in click fraud prevention, but none are as efficient as artificial intelligence (AI). Connection Model takes advantage of this innovation to perform the following tasks.  

  • Analyze traffic sources and detect invalid traffic  
  • Detect performance metric anomalies (inflated conversion and click-through rates, and engagement metrics) 
  • Block fraudulent activities  
  • Provide real-time alerts  

Thanks to its features, AI can help companies detect fraudulent clicks in PPC advertising and protect their campaigns.  

With the data it gathers, an AI-powered fraud detection program can interpret the numbers and provide actionable insights. For example, suppose the AI detects spikes in a region that typically doesn’t convert sales. In that case, it may see the activity as a red flag and inform marketers about possible courses of action. Our AI program comes with comprehensive reporting features that allow you to access the insights you’re looking for easily. Leveraging AI expedites the analysis process, in short. This way, you can recalibrate your strategies and maintain your campaign’s performance.  

The Role of Ad Networks in Click Fraud Prevention 

Ad networks play a crucial role in the fight against click fraud, employing various strategies to protect advertisers: 

  • Monitoring ad traffic: Ad networks use advanced algorithms and machine learning techniques to monitor ad traffic and detect fraudulent behavior. This continuous surveillance helps identify and prevent click fraud in real time. 

 

damian-zaleski-RYyr-k3Ysqg-unsplash
jakub-zerdzicki-ToGO4FxkwHI-unsplash
  • Implementing fraud detection software: Specialized fraud prevention software, such as IP blocking and device fingerprinting, is used by ad networks to detect and prevent click fraud. These tools help ensure that only genuine clicks are counted, protecting advertisers’ budgets. 
  • Collaborating with advertisers: Ad networks work closely with advertisers to identify and prevent click fraud. By sharing data and insights, they can improve ad campaign performance and develop more effective fraud prevention strategies. 

By understanding these various aspects of click fraud and the proactive measures taken to combat it, businesses can better protect their online advertising investments and ensure more accurate, effective campaigns. 

The Business Threats of Lead-Gen Fraud  

Following up on leads is one of the most critical steps in digital marketing. However, engaging with fraudulent ones will only lead to wasted resources and lower conversion rates. Employees end up spending time and resources on something that’s ultimately unproductive. Another issue with lead generation fraud is the skewed data. Since some answers from your forms came from bots, tracking the real, organic submissions is harder. Your customer relations management (CRM) systems become corrupted by the unreliable data. 

Click fraud also negatively influences organic digital marketing efforts that artificially boost competitors' SEO rankings and create fake engagement on social media. This can lead to significant challenges for businesses aiming to keep their digital presence and traffic quality. 

The more concerning business threat of lead generation fraud is the increased chance of a cyber-attack. Fraudsters may use lead forms to gain access to sensitive business information. These scammers will then use this data for social engineering attacks like phishing and malware installation. Lead forms may seem like innocuous parts of your marketing efforts, but expert hackers can piece together business information to launch these more sophisticated attacks. 

melanie-deziel-fSWQPBxqClg-unsplash
campaign-creators-RSc6D7bO0fA-unsplash

Combatting Lead-Gen Fraud with Advanced Solutions  

The same programs that you can use to prevent online advertising fraud can also be effective for lead-gen fraud prevention. AI programs, for example, use advanced algorithms to analyze submissions and determine if there’s any suspicious user behavior. The software can then filter out and stop fake leads in CRM systems so that only genuine prospects reach your sales team. Thanks to these innovations, you can secure your sales pipeline and avoid chasing leads that go nowhere. 

Businesses and digital marketing teams should also implement strategies for real-time monitoring and mitigation of lead generation fraud. Several types of programs actively monitor submissions as they arrive, flagging suspicious ones for further review. If the application finds the lead to be malicious, then it can block the IP instantly and prevent the bot from making any more submissions that contaminate your sales funnel. 

Protect Your Digital Marketing and Sales Operations on Today 

Digital ad fraud is becoming more rampant as businesses move online, with click and lead-gen deception as some of the top problems. Thankfully, many fraud detection solutions exist to minimize and even prevent such issues from affecting your marketing budget and GTM strategy, such as AI and cybersecurity tools.

Learning how to stop click fraud with these strategies becomes vital in avoiding these attacks. Explore these solutions with Connection Model today or learn directly from the software solution we recommend: Cheq.

The leader in fraud detection and prevention among F500 Enterprise companies for years, they recently announced a Small to Mid-Size Business offering called "Essentials". 

Learn more and get a free trial of Cheq Essentials, the solution we recommend. 

scott-graham-5fNmWej4tAA-unsplash
CleanShot 2024-10-10 at 16.03.16

Ready to take the next step?

Contact us today to start a conversation about how we can help detect and prevent fraud in your online marketing. 

Prefer to go it alone? We recommend Cheq. The leader in fraud detection and prevention among F500 Enterprise companies for years, they recently announced a Small to Mid-Size Business offering called "Essentials". 

Learn more and get a free trial of Cheq Essentials, the solution we recommend. 

Written by David Carpenter, President, President & Digital Strategist of Connection Model. Find David on LinkedIn.

The Role of Ad Networks in Click Fraud Prevention 

Ad networks play a crucial role in the fight against click fraud, employing various strategies to protect advertisers: 

  • Monitoring ad traffic: Ad networks use advanced algorithms and machine learning techniques to monitor ad traffic and detect fraudulent behavior. This continuous surveillance helps identify and prevent click fraud in real time. 

 

damian-zaleski-RYyr-k3Ysqg-unsplash
  • Implementing fraud detection software: Specialized fraud prevention software, such as IP blocking and device fingerprinting, is used by ad networks to detect and prevent click fraud. These tools help ensure that only genuine clicks are counted, protecting advertisers’ budgets. 
  • Collaborating with advertisers: Ad networks work closely with advertisers to identify and prevent click fraud. By sharing data and insights, they can improve ad campaign performance and develop more effective fraud prevention strategies. 

By understanding these various aspects of click fraud and the proactive measures taken to combat it, businesses can better protect their online advertising investments and ensure more accurate, effective campaigns. 

jakub-zerdzicki-ToGO4FxkwHI-unsplash

The Business Threats of Lead-Gen Fraud  

Following up on leads is one of the most critical steps in digital marketing. However, engaging with fraudulent ones will only lead to wasted resources and lower conversion rates. Employees end up spending time and resources on something that’s ultimately unproductive. Another issue with lead generation fraud is the skewed data. Since some answers from your forms came from bots, tracking the real, organic submissions is harder. Your customer relations management (CRM) systems become corrupted by the unreliable data. 

Click fraud also negatively influences organic digital marketing efforts that artificially boost competitors' SEO rankings and create fake engagement on social media. This can lead to significant challenges for businesses aiming to keep their digital presence and traffic quality. 

The more concerning business threat of lead generation fraud is the increased chance of a cyber-attack. Fraudsters may use lead forms to gain access to sensitive business information. These scammers will then use this data for social engineering attacks like phishing and malware installation. Lead forms may seem like innocuous parts of your marketing efforts, but expert hackers can piece together business information to launch these more sophisticated attacks. 

melanie-deziel-fSWQPBxqClg-unsplash

Combatting Lead-Gen Fraud with Advanced Solutions  

The same programs that you can use to prevent online advertising fraud can also be effective for lead-gen fraud prevention. AI programs, for example, use advanced algorithms to analyze submissions and determine if there’s any suspicious user behavior. The software can then filter out and stop fake leads in CRM systems so that only genuine prospects reach your sales team. Thanks to these innovations, you can secure your sales pipeline and avoid chasing leads that go nowhere. 

Businesses and digital marketing teams should also implement strategies for real-time monitoring and mitigation of lead generation fraud. Several types of programs actively monitor submissions as they arrive, flagging suspicious ones for further review. If the application finds the lead to be malicious, then it can block the IP instantly and prevent the bot from making any more submissions that contaminate your sales funnel. 

campaign-creators-RSc6D7bO0fA-unsplash

Protect Your Digital Marketing and Sales Operations on Today 

Digital ad fraud is becoming more rampant as businesses move online, with click and lead-gen deception as some of the top problems. Thankfully, many fraud detection solutions exist to minimize and even prevent such issues from affecting your marketing budget and GTM strategy, such as AI and cybersecurity tools.

Learning how to stop click fraud with these strategies becomes vital in avoiding these attacks. Explore these solutions with Connection Model today or learn directly from the software solution we recommend: Cheq.

The leader in fraud detection and prevention among F500 Enterprise companies for years, they recently announced a Small to Mid-Size Business offering called "Essentials". 

Learn more and get a free trial of Cheq Essentials, the solution we recommend. 

scott-graham-5fNmWej4tAA-unsplash

Ready to take the next step?

Contact us today to start a conversation about how we can help detect and prevent fraud in your online marketing. 

Prefer to go it alone? We recommend Cheq. The leader in fraud detection and prevention among F500 Enterprise companies for years, they recently announced a Small to Mid-Size Business offering called "Essentials". 

Learn more and get a free trial of Cheq Essentials, the solution we recommend. 

Written by David Carpenter, President, President & Digital Strategist of Connection Model. Find David on LinkedIn.

CleanShot 2024-10-10 at 16.03.16